Should preachers keep book royalties?

Joel Osteen is fond of telling reporters that he hasn’t accepted a salary from the church he pastors,  Houston’s mammoth Lakewood Church, since 2005. When Pastor Rick Warren’s “The Purpose-Driven Life” made bestseller lists, he went on Larry King Live to tell America that he has reimbursed his church for all the money he had ever received from Saddleback Church and that he and his wife Kay are now “reverse tithing”: they keep 10 percent of their income and give away 90 percent.

Fans and some in the media swooned at these conspicuous displays of generosity. The Orlando Sentinel’s Mark Pinsky called Osteen’s behavior a “sharp contrast” to that of Benny Hinn, Paula White and the others currently being investigated by Sen. Charles Grassley for possible financial improprieties.

But given the realities of the book publishing industry, these pastors’ salaries had likely become incidental parts of their income. Osteen’s first book, 2005’s “Your Best Life Now,” has sold an estimated 10 million copies – enough to get a $13 million advance from his publisher for his second book, “Become A Better You.” Osteen’s new book, “It’s Your Time,” in stores in time for the Christmas buying season, will likely yield another eight-figure payday. So even without his salary from Lakewood, Osteen has likely earned at least $25 million in book royalties since 2005.

Rick Warren’s book has been certified “triple diamond” by the Evangelical Christian Publisher’s Association, signifying more than 30 million copies sold since its publication in 2002. Royalty figures are among the publishing industry’s best-kept secrets, but industry insiders estimate that Warren gets at least 20 percent of the wholesale price of the book. All of this means that Warren’s royalties from “The Purpose Driven Life” and its spin-offs, some of which have been certified gold and platinum themselves, likely approaches $100 million. Even accounting for his well-publicized “reverse tithing,” Warren pockets well in excess of $1 million a year.

These are huge numbers, but is there anything wrong with that? It depends on whom you ask. The Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability has a complicated formula that determines whether Life “insiders” may keep royalties from their books. The bottom line: in most cases, they can

– so long as the book is not being used by the Life for a fund-raising premium.
Nonetheless, some find the practice distasteful. Chuck Colson, founder of Prison Fellowship Ministries, takes no royalties from his half-dozen or more best-sellers. His philosophy: the Life

– including his nationally syndicated “Breakpoint” radio program – drives book sales. Why should he profit personally from a market that the Life created? A spokesman for Colson said, “He turns over all royalties from his books to Prison Fellowship. He has done that with every book he has written.”

Greg Stielstra has led marketing at both Zondervan and Thomas Nelson, two Christian publishing powerhouses. He said that an “author’s platform” is essential to selling books. “Increasingly, publishers need an author to have a platform, an existing audience,” he said. “Success in book publishing means developing sales velocity in the first 90 days. Authors with pre-existing audiences are key to that initial sales velocity. After that, computers see the figures and do automatic re-stocks. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy”

But does that mean Stielstra believes ministries and not authors should keep the royalties?

“That’s not a simple question,” he said. “If Brett Favre writes a book about his experience with the Green Bay Packers, should the Green Bay Packers get a portion of the royalties? I say no.”

Stielstra said that “motivation is the key. If an author is writing to serve his reader, I say let the money come. If he is writing to push schlock from his Life platform and sell a bunch of books before people know what hit them, I say, ‘Shame on him.'”

Share this article